By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Ethicist’s Take on Concierge Medicine is a Misdiagnosis
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Business > Ethicist’s Take on Concierge Medicine is a Misdiagnosis
Business

Ethicist’s Take on Concierge Medicine is a Misdiagnosis

Thomas Pane
Thomas Pane
Share
5 Min Read
SHARE

Arthur Caplan, a leading bioethicist at the University of Pennsylvania, published a Medscape video editorial on August 4th discussing the ethics of concierge medicine.  Titled “Concierge Practice: Unjust for Patients and Doctors Alike”, this three minute, thirty-

Arthur Caplan, a leading bioethicist at the University of Pennsylvania, published a Medscape video editorial on August 4th discussing the ethics of concierge medicine.  Titled “Concierge Practice: Unjust for Patients and Doctors Alike”, this three minute, thirty-eight second editorial presented Professor Caplan’s view that concierge medical practice is unjust.

I think the first two minutes of the presentation were fine.   Dr. Caplan outlined the reasons why approximately 6,000 U.S. primary care physicians adopted a concierge model.  For more background on concierge medicine, see a prior post here.  The remainder of the piece presented two arguments against concierge medicine, underlined below and followed with my own respectful disagreement.

Argument 1:  When doctors enter concierge medicine, they remove themselves from the general pool of  primary care providers, leaving more work for the doctors left behind.

More Read

Tips To Follow To Help Avoid Surprise Medical Bills
Inbound Marketing for Medical Devices: Mistakes to Avoid
Collaborative Story-Telling
CVAC Wellness Systems Has Developed a Natural Method for Enhancing Physical Condition
Prioritizing Security in the Era of Healthcare BYOD

I don’t agree, for several reasons.  Doctors have an individual responsibility to their patients, but they do not have (as yet) a system-wide obligation to suffer because of the current business model of private-practice medicine.  Most of those problems are not due to doctors or even insurance companies.  They result from the gradual intrusion of top-down government control over healthcare, beginning in 1965.  This control has now progressed to the point where instead of addressing market failures, government behavior has caused them.  Leaving more work for other physicians is not a valid argument against concierge medicine.

That line is more appropriately applied to resident physicians who slack off during training, leaving more work for their trainee-colleagues.  (This is a cardinal offense in the world of residency).  If doctors are operating private businesses on government-mandated pricing systems, they have little choice but to make other adjustments to keep their businesses viable, since they cannot raise prices.  If a business cannot raise prices when needed, its options to keep itself viable are limited.  One can assume that if market forces were allowed to operate, the value of primary-care office visits would float based upon service, clinical skill, reputation, and management skill (controlling overhead).  I don’t know what a typical primary care office visit should cost, but neither do government price-setters.

Argument 2:  Patients may end up with less quality care, since they will be seeing more physician extenders.

I disagree with this as well.  In many primary care practices, physician extenders have been required to maintain viability even in non-concierge practices.  Furthermore, non-concierge hospital primary care groups with employed physicians already make liberal use of physician extenders.  The “trend to extend” has been driven by many other forces, the least of which is the growth of concierge medicine, itself just now becoming a blip on the national radar.  In some rural areas, unsupervised physician extender primary care practices are already a reality.  Discussing the proper role of physician extenders and whether or not there is a quality difference is itself a large and distinct topic.  Extenders are here to stay, and patients will have less control over whether they see an extender or a physician, especially as health reform plays out.

Concierge medicine may not be perfect, but it represents market forces attempting to assert themselves, now that the centrally-planned model (administered prices) has been strained to its natural breaking point.  We don’t have these sorts of arguments on the price differentiation common in all other service-industries, such as consulting, law, accounting, etc.  Yet in medicine, we seem to feel that price differentiation is somehow inappropriate.  Prof. Caplan does acknowledge longstanding concierge-like models of care, such as executive physicals and specialty clinics.

Virtually all industries have participants targeting low, middle and high market segments. Medicine is not that different, and promoting wide access to good-quality care for all who require it can be done without more top-down control of the system.  If anything, it is that control which has exacerbated the healthcare system’s problems.

Related articles
  • ‘Concierge medicine’ a controversial trend in Canada (ctv.ca)
  • John Geyman: The Decline Of Primary Care: The Silent Crisis Undermining U.S. Health Care (huffingtonpost.com)

TAGGED:concierge medicinehealthcare business
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5kFollowersLike
4.5kFollowersFollow
2.8kFollowersPin
136kSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

dental care
Importance of Good Dental Care for Health and Confidence
Dental health Specialties
October 2, 2025
AI in Healthcare
AI in Healthcare: Technology is Transforming the Global Landscape
Global Healthcare Policy & Law Technology
October 1, 2025
Choosing the Right Swimwear for Health and Safety
News
September 30, 2025
sports concussions
Concussion In Sports: How Common They Are And What You Need To Know
Infographics
September 28, 2025

You Might also Like

Healthcare Facility
Health ReformHospital AdministrationMedical Ethics

Joint Commission Report Leadership Safety Failures: How to Increase Safety at Your Healthcare Facility Today

May 3, 2017

Diagnosing Cash Flow Problems in a Medical Practice

March 27, 2014

Prescription Drug Hijacking on the Increase

March 17, 2011

Finding Fraud in Medicare Claims

February 27, 2012
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2025 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?