We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Fee-for-Service Again
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Business > Finance > Fee-for-Service Again
BusinessFinanceHospital AdministrationPolicy & Law

Fee-for-Service Again

Greg Scandlen
Greg Scandlen
Share
5 Min Read
Fee-for-service care
SHARE

Fee-for-service careUSA Today asked me to write a counterpoint to their editorial calling for the abolition of Fee-For-Service payment in health care.

Fee-for-service careUSA Today asked me to write a counterpoint to their editorial calling for the abolition of Fee-For-Service payment in health care. Their editorial is here, and my counter is here.

Unfortunately, USA Today did not show me the article I was responding to. Now that I have read it, I want to make a few other observations.

First, the paper thinks that putting physicians on salary would curb the problem of overtreatment. Yes, it might do that, and replace one problem with another — under treatment. Physicians might become clock-watchers, punching in at 9:00 and out at 5:00, regardless of patient need. While on the clock, they might slow-walk their services. After all, why hurry when you get the same pay regardless of how much work you do? Even factories have long figured this one out, preferring to pay piecework instead of flat wages.

More Read

5 Collection Strategies That Won’t Ruin Your Relationship with Patients
Health 2.0 Europe: “Improving and Enriching the Patient-Provider Relationship”
Ebola: Are We Relying on EHR to Tell the Story?
Medical Device Approval Process Under Fire
The Aesthetics and Reconstructive Surgery Products Global Market

But USA Today sees a more insidious problem in health care. It believes some physicians are “greedy, incompetent, and crooked.” No doubt that is true. I expect some newspaper editors are also “greedy, incompetent, and crooked.” Does placing doctors on salary solve that problem? No, it would actually worsen it for at least a couple of reasons. First, the physician would no longer be responsible for securing and paying for his own malpractice insurance. He would be covered by an enterprise-wide policy that minimizes his own culpability. Second, greedy, incompetent and crooked employees are very good at hiding in a big bureaucracy. They can always find someone else to blame for their own misdeeds and be shielded by workplace rules. Have you noticed how hard it has been to fire Lois Lerner from the IRS?

The paper says, “Ideally, doctors do no more than a patient needs.” Well, yes. But it is often hard to tell in advance what is “more than a patient needs,” and if doing “no more than needed” is the imperative, we might often end up doing less than the patient needs, with tragic consequences. If we place a ceiling on what the doctor does, if we punish him for doing more, he may err on the side of caution and often do less.

The paper also wants us to “encourage second opinions.” Good grief. Getting second opinions has been touted as a panacea for at least the last 30 years. Most of the research I have seen says that the second opinion almost always confirms the first opinion, but adds to costs because the second opinion is not cheap. That does not mean second opinions shouldn’t be done. Individual patients will be comforted if the first is confirmed or may change her mind if it is counter to the first. But there is no guarantee that the second opinion will be more valid than the first, and if the two conflict it may be necessary to get a third.

Finally, the paper says something I can agree with –

…[O]ne of the most effective ways to cut down on unnecessary operations is for doctors to share the decision-making with their patients by pointing out alternatives…

Yes, indeed. But it helps if the patient is holding the checkbook during that conversation. That is the only equalizer the patient has when negotiating with the doctor. The doctor can explain the advantages and disadvantages of each alternative, and what the costs will be! And the patient can then make a fully-informed decision. But that implies something USA Today has been railing against — a system in which fees reflect the services provided.  Otherwise, in a salaried system, the doctor will be advocating for the easiest, cheapest alternative and the patient will be suspicious of the recommendation and push for the most complicated and costly choice.

There is simply no substitute for a fee-for-service system in which the patient pays.

(Fee-for-service care / shutterstock)

TAGGED:fee for service
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5KFollowersLike
4.5KFollowersFollow
2.8KFollowersPin
136KSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: Healthcare volunteer communication as a two-way, coordinator-supported process for confirming schedu
How to Manage Volunteer Communication in Healthcare: 5 Tactical Steps and Software Options
Global Healthcare
November 18, 2026
The Nervous System Reset Guide: Simple Ways To Manage Stress -- AI-generated illustration
The Nervous System Reset Guide: Simple Ways To Manage Stress
Infographics Mental Health
November 14, 2026
Flat editorial illustration: A single digital quality-management platform connects document control, electronic approval, audit r
6 Best QMS Software Platforms for ISO 13485 and FDA Part 820 (QMSR)
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
November 12, 2026
Flat editorial illustration: Healthcare editorial illustration about accurate patient intake connecting registration, clinical re
The Role of Patient Data Accuracy in Healthcare Operations
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
November 11, 2026

You Might also Like

ACOs
BusinessFinanceHealth ReformHospital AdministrationPolicy & Law

Will Physicians Ever Embrace ACOs?

September 21, 2014

Five Ways to Boost Patient Satisfaction Scores

November 10, 2012
healthcare IT
Health ReformPolicy & LawPublic Health

Telemedicine’s Achilles’ Heel: The Telephone

May 16, 2013
socap
Global HealthcareHealth ReformPublic Health

We Need to Measure What Counts, Not What We’re Paid to Count

July 16, 2014
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2026 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?