We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Malpractice Defense: Diagnostic Laparoscopy Resulting in Bowel Injury
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Malpractice Defense: Diagnostic Laparoscopy Resulting in Bowel Injury
Policy & Law

Malpractice Defense: Diagnostic Laparoscopy Resulting in Bowel Injury

DavidEWilliams
DavidEWilliams
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

I’m the former chairman of the board of Advanced Practice Strategies (APS), a medical risk management firm that provides litigation support for malpractice defense and an eLearning curriculum focused on enhancing patient safety. I continue to follow the company closely and am intrigued by its illustrated verdict series.

To learn more contact: Timothy Croke, General Manager of Demonstrative Evidence Group. tcroke@aps-web.com or (617) 275-7300 x7264.

Here’s the latest featured case:

 

More Read

The Future of Healthcare: Part I, How the Empowered Patient Can Fix a Broken System
Is Sugar Carcinogenic?
Immigrant Lobby in Vermont Quick to Deride Single-Payer Bill
Patient Engagement Explored at the ePharma Summit
Text-to-911 Availability Has Important mHealth Implications

I’m the former chairman of the board of Advanced Practice Strategies (APS), a medical risk management firm that provides litigation support for malpractice defense and an eLearning curriculum focused on enhancing patient safety. I continue to follow the company closely and am intrigued by its illustrated verdict series.

To learn more contact: Timothy Croke, General Manager of Demonstrative Evidence Group. tcroke@aps-web.com or (617) 275-7300 x7264.

Here’s the latest featured case:

 

Judgment for the Defense
Diagnostic Laparoscopy
Resulting in Bowel Injury

http://www.aps-web.com/projectreview/IV/IV_v1_2012web/1650m3_2580m1_small.jpg

A 46-year-old woman presented with pelvic pain.  She was known to have dense adhesions in her abdomen and pelvis, discovered when undergoing a hysterectomy and a bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy (removal of fallopian tubes and ovaries along with uterus and cervix) about 7 years prior.  The defendant recommended that she have a diagnostic laparoscopy to determine the cause of her pain, suspecting an ovarian remnant, notorious for causing pain.  During the procedure, a large amount of adhesions and several loops of bowel were found adherent to the right pelvic side wall.  After dissecting the bowel off of the side wall, the defendant uncovered what was believed to be an ovarian remnant near the infundibulopelvic ligament and sent a tissue sample to pathology for review.

The following day, the plaintiff presented to the emergency room with marked abdominal pain, distension and tachycardia.  These symptoms raised concern for a possible bowel injury, so she was brought back to the operating room where a 1 cm defect was found in the terminal ileumapproximately 6 inches from the ileocecal valve.  Additionally, the pathology report from her procedure the day before reported the presumed “ovarian remnant” was actually a segment of small bowel wall with serosal fibrosis.

PLAINTIFF’S CLAIM:

The defendant was negligent in removing a piece of small bowel wall rather than an ovarian remnant.  She was also at fault for not thoroughly examining the bowel at the time of the procedure to ensure it was not injured during dissection of the dense adhesions.

DEFENSE’S ARGUMENT:

The defendant followed standard of care by carefully examining the bowel during the procedure but the adhesions and fibrosis of the bowel serosa made it difficult to identify a defect in the bowel.  The defense also argued that the size of the tissue sent to pathology, if taken directly from the terminal ileum, would have resulted in symptoms of a bowel perforation almost immediately following the procedure, and not a day later.  They proposed the perforation likely stemmed from a small tear in the bowel wall, created by pulling on adhesions during the dissection, which opened up over time.
_______________________________________________

VISUAL STRATEGY:

Collaborating with the defense attorney, APS created a visual strategy that helped experts explain that the defendant properly followed standard of care during the procedure by removing what was believed to be an ovarian remnant.

Several diagrams were used to help the jury understand the anatomy of the female pelvis and bowel.

  • Normal female pelvic anatomy, superior view
  • Normal female pelvic anatomy, anterior and sagittal views
  • Normal digestive system
  • Normal dissection of the abdomen
  • Normal small bowel blood supply

Another diagram was developed to show the hysterectomy and bilateral oophorectomy the plaintiff had approximately 7 years prior.

Another diagram demonstrated the diagnostic laparoscopy performed by the defendant.

The final diagram illustrated how a small bowel injury to the outer serosal layer can progress to a full thickness defect in the bowel wall.

This series of illustrations helped the defense successfully convey to the jury the following key points:

  • The amount and location of adhesions in this case made it difficult to identify a defect in the bowel at the time of the procedure. 
  • Illustrating the location of the removed tissue helped show it could have been mistaken for an ovarian remnant and also that the defendant did not take it directly from the bowel as the plaintiff claimed.
  • A bowel perforation can develop over time and not result only from an injury during surgery—an explanation more consistent with the timing of the plaintiff’s procedure and presentation of her symptoms. 


RESULT:
The jury found in favor of the defense. 

“Defense verdict after 5 minutes of deliberation; your illustrations were very helpful. Thanks for handling on stat basis!”

– Attorney Ritchie E. Berger, Esq., Dinse, Knapp & McAndrew, P.C.,
Burlington, VT

 


TAGGED:Malpractice
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5KFollowersLike
4.5KFollowersFollow
2.8KFollowersPin
136KSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: Healthcare volunteer communication as a two-way, coordinator-supported process for confirming schedu
How to Manage Volunteer Communication in Healthcare: 5 Tactical Steps and Software Options
Global Healthcare
November 18, 2026
The Nervous System Reset Guide: Simple Ways To Manage Stress -- AI-generated illustration
The Nervous System Reset Guide: Simple Ways To Manage Stress
Infographics Mental Health
November 14, 2026
Flat editorial illustration: A single digital quality-management platform connects document control, electronic approval, audit r
6 Best QMS Software Platforms for ISO 13485 and FDA Part 820 (QMSR)
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
November 12, 2026
Flat editorial illustration: Healthcare editorial illustration about accurate patient intake connecting registration, clinical re
The Role of Patient Data Accuracy in Healthcare Operations
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
November 11, 2026

You Might also Like

malpractice
Health ReformPolicy & Law

Medical Malpractice Reform Just Won’t Go Away

March 26, 2015
health insurance exchanges
Health ReformPolicy & Law

October 1st: A Date to Show That Everyone Matters

October 3, 2013
The ACA has put patients at the center of healthcare services. A patient-centric healthcare approach in this digital era means a revised definition of quality in the physician-patient relationship. When it comes to healthcare services, patients shell out a hefty amount from their pocket and want nothing less than the best. The services in healthcare are no longer limited to just cost as consumers now evaluate quality and experience in the same equation. Research highlights from the 2015 Healthcare Consumer Trends by National Research Corporation states that reputation in healthcare matters more to consumers when choosing a brand than any other industry, e.g. hospitality, retail, airline, etc. The new generation of quality measurements in healthcare require a different mind-set and a different 'toolbox' to handle the hurdles. It’s the need of the hour for healthcare providers and others across the healthcare value chain to adopt the patient-centric approach for surviving in the vast competitive ocean of healthcare services. Patient-centric care is an approach that develops through effective communication, empathy and a positive physician-patient relationship. The primary purpose is to improve patient care outcomes and satisfaction and to reduce patient symptoms and unnecessary costs. It’s a win-win situation for both physicians and patients. While healthcare providers are able to support their patients in becoming more compliant with treatment and management of their conditions/diseases, patients feel more satisfied with the care that they are receiving. PwC’s Health Research Institute’s annual report 2016 states that health systems should keep an eye on the consumer experience as they expand and extend. More partnerships and more caregivers could mean confusion for patients and poor customer experiences. To differentiate their practice among competitors, patient satisfaction can be used as a competitive distinguishing factor. Although patient satisfaction cannot really provide tangible benefits, but an experience that exceeds patient expectations for what a practice/hospital can provide is very important as it creates loyal patients who return for future health needs and refer their family and friends. Happy and satisfied patients are a secret marketing weapon for healthcare providers, whether they are physicians, dentists, physiotherapists or hospitals. Your patients are the new-age digital health decision-makers. In this era of Internet and social media, they now have multichannel access to information related to health. Needless to mention, they have gained new power to make their decisions; whether it’s choosing a healthcare provider or referring a physician to family and friends. By converting your satisfied patients to be your brand advocates, you can capitalize and use their voice as an effective marketing strategy to reach out to many other potential patients. To strive and thrive, in the U.S. many healthcare organizations are applying patient-centric approaches to healthcare. It’s all about what matters to patients, so it makes a lot of sense for the healthcare industry to place patients' healthcare experience at the center of their policies and procedures. The best deliverables are a combination of great communication for a positive physician-patient relationship, disciplined measurement and analysis of patient feedback and commitment to technology innovation – the formula for improving patient engagement and care.
BusinessHealth ReformWellness

The Link Between Patient Satisfaction and Long-Lasting Relationships

April 28, 2016
Image
Public Health

DeathWise.org – DIY End of Life Planning

May 11, 2012
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2026 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?