We use cookies, including third-party cookies from Google to serve personalized ads through AdSense, to operate this site and understand how it is used. By continuing to browse, you accept this use. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use for details, including how to opt out of personalized advertising.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Repeal Without Replace Starts Destroying GOP’s Chances
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Health Reform > Repeal Without Replace Starts Destroying GOP’s Chances
Health Reform

Repeal Without Replace Starts Destroying GOP’s Chances

DavidEWilliams
DavidEWilliams
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) gave Republicans a great big target to shoot at, and they’ve worked up so much energy attacking so-called ObamaCare that they’ve dug themselves into a great big hole on health care. It may well be enough to keep them from control of the White House and maybe the Hill, too if things keep going the way they’re going.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) gave Republicans a great big target to shoot at, and they’ve worked up so much energy attacking so-called ObamaCare that they’ve dug themselves into a great big hole on health care. It may well be enough to keep them from control of the White House and maybe the Hill, too if things keep going the way they’re going.

Jonathan Chait has an excellent essay in the May 26 New Republic (You Got Nothing) that points out that not only have Republicans forgotten the “replace” part of “repeal and replace,” but that they’ve put themselves in a spot where they will never be able to come up with a health plan.

Taking control of Congress again this year, Republicans immediately set about undoing health care reform. Carefully following the advice of pollsters, however, they insisted their true goal was not to overturn the law but to “repeal and replace.” The effort began with a straight-up vote to repeal health care reform and replace it with, technically speaking, nothing whatsoever. But fear not! “Repeal is the first, not the last step,” wrote Ryan and four other Republican chairmen. “Compassionate, innovative and job-creating health care reform is what’s next.”

More Read

wall street journal health policy
Wall Street Journal Shames Itself with Health Policy Coverage
Hospital Selfies and Stars: Patients Look Deeper Than HCAHPS
Affordable Care: Your Prospective Patients Are Mighty Confused
Collaborating for Population Health Management Strategy
Cartoon Version of Obamacare is Pretty Useful [video]

Alas, the race to discover this compassionate, innovative, job-creating health care plan has proceeded with all the urgency of O.J. Simpson’s search for the true murderer of his late wife and her paramour…

Conservatives adore Ryan’s budget perhaps because it liberates them from the exhausting burden of pretending to care about the uninsured. It begins with the assumption of perfect markets everywhere and dispatches any attempt to correct for market failures—by, say, covering the uninsured—in purely ideological terms. (Subsidizing insurance for those who can’t afford it leaves them “helplessly dependent on their government.”) Inside this snug little loop of reasoning, if the answer isn’t the free market, you’re asking the wrong question.

But there’s a little problem here, which is that there are at least a couple of relatively serious thinkers contemplating the Republican nomination. And they’re not yet ready to buy in completely to the lazy Ryan-style thinking and to reflexively label everything in PPACA as a terrible idea. Last week Mitt Romney stepped into the limelight and botched his attempt to square his leadership role in enacting the PPACA prototype in Massachusetts (complete with individual mandate) with his avowed desire to overturn PPACA right when he gets into office. As I wrote, it is actually an intellectually defensible position, but he didn’t present that way.

Now along comes Newt Gingrich, who (shockingly!) called it like it is on the Ryan budget plan. From the Wall Street Journal (Gingrich to House GOP: Drop Dead)

The Ryan program “is too big a jump,” he said. “I think what you want to have is a system where people voluntarily migrate to better outcomes, better solutions, better options. Not one where you suddenly impose upon you—I don’t want to—I—I’m against ObamaCare, which is imposing radical change. And I would be against a conservative imposing radical change.”

Today Gingrich is back, towing the line. But, like Romney, he’s put forth serious health care reform ideas in the past, including mandates. That’s just not going to play in today’s GOP primary environment.

When PPACA was passed I was among those who expected that it might become popular, at least in time for the 2012 election, as people started to enjoy some of the benefits it provided. I underestimated how broadly and strongly it would be attacked, but I also took the GOP at its word that “repeal and replace” wouldn’t amount to repeal only.

Republican primary voters may or may not care that “replace” has been cast aside. But at the very least the moderate center is likely to wake up by the time of the general election and realize that we have to do be serious about health care reform in this country, and that simplistic, ideological solutions aren’t up to the task at hand. Serious Republican contenders for President understand this, which may be one reason they’ve been so slow to get into the race.

You can bet the White House is quietly enjoying the fratricide.


TAGGED:health care reform
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5KFollowersLike
4.5KFollowersFollow
2.8KFollowersPin
136KSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Flat editorial illustration: Healthcare volunteer communication as a two-way, coordinator-supported process for confirming schedu
How to Manage Volunteer Communication in Healthcare: 5 Tactical Steps and Software Options
Global Healthcare
November 18, 2026
The Nervous System Reset Guide: Simple Ways To Manage Stress -- AI-generated illustration
The Nervous System Reset Guide: Simple Ways To Manage Stress
Infographics Mental Health
November 14, 2026
Flat editorial illustration: A single digital quality-management platform connects document control, electronic approval, audit r
6 Best QMS Software Platforms for ISO 13485 and FDA Part 820 (QMSR)
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
November 12, 2026
Flat editorial illustration: Healthcare editorial illustration about accurate patient intake connecting registration, clinical re
The Role of Patient Data Accuracy in Healthcare Operations
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
November 11, 2026

You Might also Like

health-care-reform-overview
Health ReformMedical RecordsNewsPolicy & Law

Healthcare Reform’s Impact: Staff and Service Cuts Expected

December 15, 2011

Health Insurance Benefits: Can You Have It Your Way?

August 19, 2014
HIE cash payment
BusinessHealth ReformPolicy & Law

Unintended Consequences: How HIEs Force Patients to Quit Their PCPs

July 3, 2014

The Future of Consumer-Directed Health Care

March 7, 2011
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2026 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?