By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    UV damage to eyes
    Warning Signs of Long-Term UV Damage to Your Eyes
    December 9, 2021
    degree for healthcare job
    The Ultimate Healthcare Recruiting and Staffing Guidebook
    March 21, 2022
    medicare part d benefits
    Everything that You Need to Know About Medicare Part D
    August 15, 2022
    Latest News
    Getting Back in the Game: Sports Injuries Rehabilitation Tips
    May 31, 2023
    4 Signs It’s Time to See a Therapist
    May 24, 2023
    11 Ways To Modernize Your Private Practice
    May 17, 2023
    How to Recognize the Signs of Hormonal Imbalance in Men
    May 29, 2023
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    Book Summary: The Future of Health Care Delivery
    January 9, 2012
    Collaborative Care for Living Well with Chronic Disease
    February 5, 2012
    CMS to Announce ACO Regs Soon
    August 26, 2017
    Latest News
    MRI Sedation Options: What You Should Know Before Screening
    May 17, 2023
    What is the Process of Creating Medicine from Nature?
    May 2, 2023
    Choosing the Right Treatment Option for Varicose Veins
    May 2, 2023
    What Are Wrong-Site Surgeries and How Do They Occur?
    April 27, 2023
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: The Death Of Disease Management (Finally)
Share
Sign In
Notification Show More
Aa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Aa
Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Wellness > Home Health > The Death Of Disease Management (Finally)
BusinessHome HealthPolicy & LawPublic Health

The Death Of Disease Management (Finally)

Archelle Georgiou
Last updated: 2012/01/13 at 9:03 AM
Archelle Georgiou
Share
8 Min Read
SHARE

   In 1995, Dr. Steven Rosenberg published an article in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) that fueled the start of an industry.  In a randomized, controlled trial, he showed that an investing in proactive disease management (DM) activities could decrease the cost and improve the quality of life for patients with congestive heart failure.

The premise of disease management seemed intuitive:
·      Systematically assure that evidence-based medicine is applied.
·      Educate and empower patients to practice self-care.
·      Intensely manage the sickest 5-10% of the patients driving 80% of the costs.

Healthplans, employers and other payers (and I) jumped on the bandwagon hoping that these programs would be a consumer-friendly silver bullet to escalating health care costs.

Cardiac Solutions, Matria, LifeMasters and American Healthways, among others, became household names. In addition, business opportunities abounded: 
·      Disease Management Association of America was founded in 1999.
·      NCQA developed an DM accreditation program in 2002.
·      Data analytics companies developed predictive modeling tools to better identify the highest risk patients.
·      Employee benefits consultants promoted the “new new thing” for cost control.

But, behind the scenes, there was a lot of hand-wringing.  On the eve of a major Disease Management conference, circa 2004, I remember sitting in the bar of an Orlando hotel having cocktails with DM gurus who who’d nabbed the coveted keynote speaker spots at this major forum. The Medicare Modernization Act of 2003 had just passed, and CMS had a mandate to test the disease management model in Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries. I was shocked when my industry colleagues admitted that this $20 billion industry would only last as long as it would take for the pilots programs to be completed and CMS to analyze the results.

In the mean time…double-digit healthcare cost inflation fueled employers demand for a wide array of condition-specific programs as a cost reduction strategy.  According to Mercer Consulting, in 2010, 73% of employers offered disease management programs even though consistent, reproducible evidence of a positive ROI is still lacking.

It’s been seven long years since that Orlando meeting…and the time has come when will disease management may finally…finally…. fizzle and die.

The CMS demonstration programs started between August 2005 and January 2006 and preliminary results reported in 2008  concluded that “Results to date indicate limited success in achieving Medicare cost savings or reducing acute care utilization.”   The individual programs, all using nurse-based call centers, ended between December 2006 and August 2008, and the definitive results were published in NEJM in November 2011.  In summary:
  • Only 2 of 15 programs resulted in reduced hospital admissions. None generated net savings.
  • There were only 14 significant improvements in process-of-care measures out of 40 comparisons.
  • These modest improvements came at substantial cost to the Medicare program in fees paid to the disease management companies ($400 million), with “no demonstrable savings in Medicare expenditures.”

So, why did this intuitive approach to managing disease fail?

In my opinion, there have been 3 critical missteps in the evolution of this industry:
1)    NCQA Accreditation Standards: NCQA’s health plan accreditation standards require that DM programs be population-based—in other words, that ALL individuals with a condition be eligible for participation–not just those at highest risk who are most likely to benefit clinically and financially.  Healthplans and vendors complied to achieve the marketing value of the NCQA gold seal of approval. Employers bought into this approach in the spirit of “prevention.”  However, this peanut butter approach allocates time and money to individuals who are so low risk that there is little opportunity for clinically meaningful improvement that translates into financial savings.
2)  Toys and Trinkets: From glossy brochures to felt puppets to refrigerator magnets, DM companies have differentiated themselves with collateral materials that have sales appeal but have little impact on improving care or decreasing utilization.  At the same time, all these all of these items inflate program costs and erode ROI.  At the end of the day, DM that does not achieve a net savings is not successful.
3)   Over-reliance on Evidence-Based Medicine: Yes, EBM is the wholly grail. However, the sole reliance on these standards in disease management interventions does not actually “manage disease” since avoidable costs are frequently due to subtle opportunities and gaps in care that exist as a result of multiple co-morbidities.  For example: A patient in a diabetes DM program may also have rheumatoid arthritis. If the patient’s hand/joint pain is not well managed, it is unlikely that she will be able to comply with manually operating a glucometer to check her blood sugars. Unfortunately, the critical thinking required to truly coordinate care is difficult to systematically build into program design….therefore, too often, its absent.

So, if disease management doesn’t work, what does?
This month, hundreds of health care entities will be submitting proposals to CMS to get a piece of the $1 billion funding available through the Health Care Innovation Challenge.   As CMS grants between $1 M and $30 M to various projects, let’s hope that they fund initiatives that reflect fresh, not “same old, same old”  thinking for improving health and decreasing cost. 
Technologies and platforms that are relatively low cost, scalable and seem the most promising are those that leverage:
1)    Social networking—Condition-specific communities of patients continue to proliferate and the user-generated content from “people just like me” is having a positive impact on compliance, self-care, and quality of life.
2)    Gaming: Health gaming is extending far beyond Wii Fit. Game developers are designing increasing numbers of consumer-oriented applications that address prevention, healthy lifestyles and disease self-management.
3)   Remote monitoring: Biometric and ambient activity sensors offer clinicians and caregivers 24/7 insight to a person’s clinical status so that care can be delivered when it’s needed rather than when it’s scheduled.
4)    Mobile/wireless health management applications: In addition to consumer focused health management apps, mobile and wireless access to patient medical information accelerates how physicians make critical diagnostic decisions and can prevent delays in care.

5)   Environmental solutions:  Innovative companies are poised to transform health care with disruptive products and systems that rely on design thinking–solutions that make it easy to be healthy, passively and continuously support better health,  and don’t rely on individual behavior change.
Proposals are due January 27, 2012. Awards will be announced in March. Results won’t be in for 3 years.
In the mean time, employers looking for immediate health care cost savings can save $2-5 per member per month in fees by terminating their disease management programs. 

Disease Management: RIP


. 


TAGGED: Disease management

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Archelle Georgiou January 13, 2012
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Share
Previous Article Oxycontin and Heroin Addiction: Business Opportunities in the Push to Address the Problem
Next Article Video: Tips for Overcoming the Gray Areas of Meaningful Use Stage 1 for Safety Net Providers

Stay Connected

1.5k Followers Like
4.5k Followers Follow
2.8k Followers Pin
136k Subscribers Subscribe

Latest News

medical bills
Who is Responsible for Paying the Medical Bills After an Injury?
News June 1, 2023
sports injury rehabilitation
Getting Back in the Game: Sports Injuries Rehabilitation Tips
Health May 31, 2023
brush your day
How Many Times A Day Should You Brush Your Teeth?
Dental health May 29, 2023
Chiropractic Laser Therapy: A Beacon of Hope for Chronic Pain Sufferers
Chiropractic Laser Therapy: A Beacon of Hope for Chronic Pain Sufferers
Therapies May 29, 2023

You Might also Like

MRI sedation options
Global Healthcare

MRI Sedation Options: What You Should Know Before Screening

May 17, 2023
medicines from nature
Global Healthcare

What is the Process of Creating Medicine from Nature?

May 2, 2023
varicose veins treatments
Health

Choosing the Right Treatment Option for Varicose Veins

May 2, 2023
wrong-site surgery
Policy & Law

What Are Wrong-Site Surgeries and How Do They Occur?

April 27, 2023
//

We influence million of users and is the most authentic source of information on healthcare business and technology news.

Quick Links

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Follow US

© 2008-2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?