By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    How Not to Become a Victim of Medical Scams
    How Not to Become a Victim of Medical Scams
    December 22, 2021
    11 Ways You Can Care for Your Elder Family Members Health
    11 Ways You Can Care for Your Elder Family Members Health
    April 6, 2022
    How Can Brain Injury Lead To Dangerous Long-Term Effects?
    How Can Brain Injury Lead To Dangerous Long-Term Effects?
    August 30, 2022
    Latest News
    Getting Back in the Game: Sports Injuries Rehabilitation Tips
    May 31, 2023
    4 Signs It’s Time to See a Therapist
    May 24, 2023
    11 Ways To Modernize Your Private Practice
    May 17, 2023
    How to Recognize the Signs of Hormonal Imbalance in Men
    May 29, 2023
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    Why We Need To Be More Open About End-of-Life Care
    April 30, 2020
    accident injuries healthworkscollective
    Beyond the Fender Bender: Accident Injuries, Actions, and Recovery
    February 5, 2021
    Data Mining And Healthcare: How Treatment Can Be Improved By Data Collection
    February 21, 2020
    Latest News
    MRI Sedation Options: What You Should Know Before Screening
    May 17, 2023
    What is the Process of Creating Medicine from Nature?
    May 2, 2023
    Choosing the Right Treatment Option for Varicose Veins
    May 2, 2023
    What Are Wrong-Site Surgeries and How Do They Occur?
    April 27, 2023
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Krugman: Wrong Again About ObamaCare
Share
Sign In
Notification Show More
Aa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Aa
Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Health Reform > Krugman: Wrong Again About ObamaCare
Health ReformPolicy & Law

Krugman: Wrong Again About ObamaCare

JohnCGoodman
Last updated: 2013/12/12 at 9:11 AM
JohnCGoodman
Share
7 Min Read
krugman's wrong about obamacare
SHARE

What I’m about to show you is in my opinion an embarrassment to the economics profession and I wish more of my colleagues would express their strong disapproval.

What I’m about to show you is in my opinion an embarrassment to the economics profession and I wish more of my colleagues would express their strong disapproval.

Take a look at the blue line in the chart below. It shows the annual rate of change in U.S. health care spending. Now here is what Paul Krugman wrote in his New York Times column the other day:

… the facts are striking. Since 2010, when the [the Affordable Care Act] was passed, real health spending per capita — that is, total spending adjusted for overall inflation and population growth — has risen less than a third as rapidly as its long-term average. Real spending per Medicare recipient hasn’t risen at all; real spending per Medicaid beneficiary has actually fallen slightly.

More Read

comparative negligence

Not Knowing About Comparative Negligence Can Worsen Your Medical Debt

The Role Addiction Plays in Increasing the Risk of Traffic Accidents
What Are Bioidentical Hormones Made With?
Cover Medical Costs of Child Dog Bites with Legal Specialists
3 Ways to Improve the U.S. Healthcare System By 2030

He then goes on to consider a number of possible causes for this slowdown, but appears to give the lion’s share of the credit to ObamaCare. In fact his column is titled, “ObamaCare’s Secret Success.”

All of which is pointless speculation, because as the chart clearly shows, nothing happened to the rate of increase in health care spending in 2010 ― the year ObamaCare was passed.

Yes, the growth rate of health care spending that year was well below the historical average. But it was just as much below it in 2009, the year before the act was passed! Health care spending growth in 2010 was exactly the same as it was in 2009. It remained exactly the same in 2011. And again in 2012. Looking only at the numbers, we would have to conclude that nothing that happened in 2010 had any impact whatsoever on health care spending. Nothing Congress did; nothing the president did; nothing that anyone did that year seems to have mattered.

krugman's wrong about obamacare

Taken from Joe Antos, Testimony before the Senate Committee on the Budget.

 

Here is something else Krugman failed to inform readers about: as the chart clearly shows, the  slowdown in the rate of health care inflation has been steady and stretches over almost the entire decade before the Affordable Care Act became law. Whatever the cause, it started early on George Bush’s watch ― not under Barrack Obama.

Moreover, ObamaCare doesn’t really begin until this coming January. All the changes up to now have been cost increasing ― providing risk pool insurance to the uninsurable, forcing private plans to cover more benefits, and adding such extras to Medicare as free “wellness exams.”

So how does Krugman manage to give ObamaCare any credit for a slowdown in spending? He begins by noting that a 2011 letter signed by hundreds of health and labor economists pointed out that “the Affordable Care Act contains essentially every cost-containment provision policy analysts have considered effective in reducing the rate of medical spending.”

Sad to say, but there are members of my profession who will occasionally sign their names to nonsense. Even so, shouldn’t readers be told that the letter and the Congressional testimony of the letter’s organizer, Harvard professor David Cutler, have been completely discredited by University of Chicago professor Casey Mulligan and other reputable economists ― scholars who actually looked at the facts instead of signing on to shoot-from-the-hip rhetoric.

And shouldn’t readers be informed that every reputable forecast made by serious economists has concluded that ObamaCare will add to health care spending, rather than detract from it. For example, the Medicare actuaries predict that ObamaCare will add $625 billion to total health care spending over the next decade. And the RAND Corporation predicts that consumers in the ObamaCare exchanges will pay almost $2,000 more for health insurance than they otherwise would by 2016.

Krugman has other arrows in his quiver. For example, he claims ObamaCare:

  • Has cut payments to private Medicare Advantage plans. But most of these were postponed until after the 2012 election and don’t really kick in until next year.
  • Has cut some provider payments. So far, these have been minuscule.
  • Has begun to penalize hospitals with high readmission rates. But this program was started only recently and so far the savings are scant.
  • Has encouraged doctors and hospitals to organize into accountable care organizations, where Medicare payments will be partly based on performance. But the number participating so far is small and there appears to be little evidence of success in reducing in costs or improving in quality.

Further, Krugman must surely know that the federal government has been funding dozens of pilot programs and demonstration projects to see if different methods of payment under Medicare will reduce costs and improve quality. Yet three separate Congressional Budget Office reports have found that these experiments are not working. (See here, here and here.)

There is one final bit of deception. Krugman writes that:

…there’s evidence that Medicare savings “spill over” to the rest of the health care system — that when Medicare manages to slow cost growth, private insurance gets cheaper, too.

Well not quite. The study found that this is true not for Medicare, but for private (Medicare Advantage) plans that Krugman generally rails against for being less efficient than government insurance and that receive fees that ObamaCare is scheduled to cut.

Finally, here is Bob Laszewski making some of these same points at The Health Care Blog.

TAGGED: paul krugman

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
JohnCGoodman December 12, 2013
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Share
Previous Article Mastering During Difficult Situations with Patients
Next Article RSNA 2013: What Does the Power of Partnership Really Mean?

Stay Connected

1.5k Followers Like
4.5k Followers Follow
2.8k Followers Pin
136k Subscribers Subscribe

Latest News

11 ways nurses can care for patients during mental health crises
11 ways nurses can care for patients during mental health crises
Mental Health June 6, 2023
test
Essential Steps for Starting Your Journey as a Fitness Instructor
Fitness June 5, 2023
mimosa pudica
Health Benefits of Mimosa Pudica: The Marvel of Nature
News June 2, 2023
medical bills
Who is Responsible for Paying the Medical Bills After an Injury?
News June 1, 2023

You Might also Like

MRI sedation options
Global Healthcare

MRI Sedation Options: What You Should Know Before Screening

May 17, 2023
medicines from nature
Global Healthcare

What is the Process of Creating Medicine from Nature?

May 2, 2023
varicose veins treatments
Health

Choosing the Right Treatment Option for Varicose Veins

May 2, 2023
wrong-site surgery
Policy & Law

What Are Wrong-Site Surgeries and How Do They Occur?

April 27, 2023
//

We influence million of users and is the most authentic source of information on healthcare business and technology news.

Quick Links

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Follow US

© 2008-2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?