By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    photo of hands with blue veins
    8 Proven Tips on Finding Difficult Veins
    November 12, 2021
    tips for getting over the pandemic blues
    4 Proven Ways to Get Over the Pandemic Blues
    February 22, 2022
    medical industry innovations
    How is CNC Machining Transforming the Medical Industry?
    June 2, 2022
    Latest News
    Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
    May 16, 2025
    Learn how to Renew your Medical Card in West Virginia
    May 16, 2025
    Choosing the Right Supplement Manufacturer for Your Brand
    May 1, 2025
    Engineering Temporary Hospitals for Extreme Weather
    April 24, 2025
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    Doctors on Google: Manhattan Research Survey 2012
    July 23, 2012
    HealthCare’s Need for Transparency Goes Far Beyond Pricing
    December 10, 2012
    Medicare Payments to Providers Are Carved, Sliced and Chopped by Sequestration
    March 25, 2013
    Latest News
    Building Smarter Care Teams: Aligning Roles, Structure, and Clinical Expertise
    May 18, 2025
    The Critical Role of Healthcare in Personal Injury Recovery: A Comprehensive Guide for Victims
    May 14, 2025
    The Backbone of Successful Trials: Clinical Data Management
    April 28, 2025
    Advancing Your Healthcare Career through Education and Specialization
    April 16, 2025
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: The Cookie-Cutter Medicine Fallacy
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Medical Education > The Cookie-Cutter Medicine Fallacy
Medical Education

The Cookie-Cutter Medicine Fallacy

gooznews
Last updated: June 8, 2012 8:17 am
gooznews
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

By Michael Halpern

(The following is reprinted from the Health Affairs blog)

By Michael Halpern

(The following is reprinted from the Health Affairs blog)

More Read

Assessing Med School Applicants’ Digital Footprints
#Doctors20 & You Conference: #mHealth, #ePatients, #Collaboration
Healthcare Innovation: Moving from Stewardship to Leadership
Are We on the Verge of a Primary Care Renaissance?
Changing the Way We Think

About a year ago, some medical symptoms that I’ve experienced for several years suddenly got worse.  Nothing really severe, but I was concerned enough that I wanted to know if this was just a flare-up of a condition I’ve had for quite a while or if it represented a new health problem.  I went to specialist I’d seen many times before and described the changes.  He sent me for a couple of diagnostic tests, and then scheduled an appointment once he got the results.

He thought I had developed a new chronic disease – let’s call it Condition X.  Not a life-threatening condition, but one that certainly affects quality of life and can be progressive.  He wanted me to immediately start treatment for this condition, which involved medications and a substantial change in diet.

Being a health services researcher and a physician, I wanted to know more about this diagnosis.  So I looked through my medical textbooks, read the latest articles, Googled the condition, and went over the diagnosis and treatment guidelines from specialty societies.  After this, I wasn’t at all certain that I really had Condition X, so I scheduled another appointment with my specialist.

“I’m not sure about this diagnosis,” I told him.  “Results from the diagnostic tests you recommended are equivocal – right on the border between positive and negative.  Also, much of the literature says that these tests aren’t very accurate or meaningful.  More importantly, I don’t have the characteristic symptom of Condition X.  The guidelines from your professional society say that in order to be diagnosed with Condition X, patients must have this symptom.  I don’t have and have never had this characteristic and defining symptom.”

“I know,” the specialist said.  “I’m familiar with the literature and the guidelines, and know that you don’t have the main symptom that is characteristic of this condition.  However, I’ve seen a lot of patients with Condition X in my years of practice, and I have a sense about who has Condition X.  Despite this other information, I think you have Condition X.”

I left my appointment with that specialist and haven’t been back.  I felt that if a physician were more confident in his feelings than in the objective evidence, then I didn’t want him treating me.  I didn’t start the treatment he recommended.  The worsened symptoms which triggered my concerns went away a few weeks later and haven’t returned.

This vignette provides a perspective on the currently controversial subject of comparative effectiveness.  Detractors argue that comparative effectiveness will lead to “cookie-cutter medicine,” that all patients will be treated the same based on summarized evidence, and that individuals’ differences will be ignored.  My experience suggests the opposite.

When physicians choose to downplay or ignore external objective evidence, they rely instead on internal “subjective evidence” – their experience, feelings, and intuition. Experience-based judgment is a critical tool for the practice of medicine, which requires making decisions under conditions of uncertainty.  However, when diagnoses are made based primarily on judgment and beliefs, it becomes easier to ignore evidence contradicting these beliefs, and many patients might be treated in the same manner because they seem to fit in a well-known and familiar category.   Thus, ignoring external evidence such as published studies and relying instead on internal beliefs to make diagnoses may be more likely to result in the “cookie cutter medicine” that comparative effectiveness detractors fear.

I don’t think that is how most physicians want to practice medicine, or how the U.S. public wants their physicians to practice.  Physicians do need to use their previous experience, judgment, and intuition – ignoring it would be harmful.  But ignoring evidence generated by comparative effectiveness, summarizing information from hundreds or thousands of patients, is also harmful.

Perhaps the critics of comparative effectiveness research need to consider the alternatives – do they really want medical decisions made solely on the basis of what their physician feels is correct, or would they prefer that all the information, including a physician’s experience and results from previous research, be used to make the best health care decisions?  This should be a rhetorical question, but given the fervent attacks on comparative effectiveness research that often appear today, it is a question that needs to be asked.

TAGGED:cookie cutterPhysicians
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5kFollowersLike
4.5kFollowersFollow
2.8kFollowersPin
136kSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Clinical Expertise
Building Smarter Care Teams: Aligning Roles, Structure, and Clinical Expertise
Health care
May 18, 2025
Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
Health
May 15, 2025
Learn how to Renew your Medical Card in West Virginia
Learn how to Renew your Medical Card in West Virginia
Health
May 15, 2025
Dr. Klaus Rentrop Shares Acute Myocardial Infarction heart treatment
Dr. Klaus Rentrop Shares Acute Myocardial Infarction
Cardiology
May 13, 2025

You Might also Like

doctors sxsw videogames
Medical EducationMedical InnovationsNews

Teamwork + SXSW + Minecraft + Healthcare = Sum Greater Than Parts

March 28, 2013
healthcare organization
Medical Education

How Micro-Moves Can Drive Major HealthCare Change: Walking the Patient’s Path

October 10, 2013
Medical Education

Better Bedside Manners Heal Doctor-Patient Relationships

July 30, 2012

The Problem with Medical Training: We Are Not Learning About the Causes of the Causes

May 23, 2012
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2025 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?