Should Parents be Allowed to Give Teachers Gifts?

February 22, 2011
55 Views

Today’s Boston Globe (Gift limits for teachers irk givers, recipients; Many reject fears of undue influence) goes after an easy target: restrictions and reporting requirements for teachers who receive gifts from parents. Under a state advisory teachers can’t accept gifts worth more than $50 and must file written disclosures even for cheaper gifts if a “reasonable person” could think a teacher would be influenced as a result of the gift.

Today’s Boston Globe (Gift limits for teachers irk givers, recipients; Many reject fears of undue influence) goes after an easy target: restrictions and reporting requirements for teachers who receive gifts from parents. Under a state advisory teachers can’t accept gifts worth more than $50 and must file written disclosures even for cheaper gifts if a “reasonable person” could think a teacher would be influenced as a result of the gift.

The Globe story trots out the obvious objections to the policy:

  • “There’s no common sense here,” says a superintendent.
  • Teachers often use the gifts to buy something for the classroom, not themselves
  • Expensive gifts are rare
  • No one’s complained

I’m sympathetic to these arguments. And yet, experience from the pharmaceutical industry tells us that the state may actually be on to something here with its restrictions. There are a lot of reasons pharmaceutical companies give doctors gifts. Some of the big items (largely banned now) such as pricey tickets for sporting events and trips to exotic locations are straightforward attempts to buy influence.

But it’s interesting to note that pharma is still keen to give out small gifts such as pens and prescription pads and to pay for lunch. One reason they do this is that pharma understands that even small gifts create a sense of obligation on the part of the recipient. Subconsciously the doctor wants to pay the pharma rep back, and the easiest ways to do that are to spend time with the rep (when they can be influenced to prescribe a specific drug) or just to start writing more prescriptions. Even when doctors think they aren’t being influenced they often are. That’s why pharma keeps at it.

I’m not saying teachers are necessarily going to be influenced by small gifts from parents. The dynamics are different in the classroom after all. But the Globe is remiss for not exploring this angle, especially in what’s billed as a news story. Even if restrictions were removed, I’d like to see the teachers receive brief education on the psychology of gift giving so they can be aware of the dangers.

I’d like to see the same for doctors, too.

Share


You may be interested

Where Is The Balance? Pushing Back Against Consumer Health Tech
eHealth
3 views
eHealth
3 views

Where Is The Balance? Pushing Back Against Consumer Health Tech

Larry Alton - August 18, 2017

When Republican Congressman Jason Chaffetz glibly remarked that Americans struggling to afford insurance should choose between that and their smartphones,…

What to Look for in Patient Solutions Software
eHealth
365 views
eHealth
365 views

What to Look for in Patient Solutions Software

Robert Cordray - August 17, 2017

The medical sector is one area where technology has had a significant impact, largely by providing tools that simplify many…

Can Natural Remedies Like RediCalm Decrease Stress and Anxiety?
Wellness
2 views
Wellness
2 views

Can Natural Remedies Like RediCalm Decrease Stress and Anxiety?

Ryan Kh - August 16, 2017

According to research from the National Institute of Mental Health, anxiety disorders are the most common mental illness in the…