By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    An Expert’s Guide To Building and Improving Endurance
    June 30, 2022
    medical assistants
    What Do Medical Assistants Do On a Day to Day Basis?
    April 5, 2022
    superfoods to help with prostate health
    10 Healthy Foods That Can Help Protect Your Prostate
    August 29, 2022
    Latest News
    Why Custom Telemedicine Apps Outperform Off‑the‑Shelf Solutions
    July 20, 2025
    How Probate Planning Shapes the Future of Your Estate and Family Care
    July 17, 2025
    Beyond Nutrition: Everyday Foods That Support Whole-Body Health
    June 15, 2025
    The Wide-Ranging Benefits of Magnesium Supplements
    June 11, 2025
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    pfizer and clinical data transparency
    Pfizer to Expand Clinical Trial Data Access, Takes Step Toward Transparency
    December 6, 2013
    Improving Healthcare Services And Management Through Tech Integration
    June 9, 2020
    obamacare and the uninsured
    Why Hospitals Are Still Gouging the Uninsured
    January 7, 2014
    Latest News
    How IT and Marketing Teams Can Collaborate to Protect Patient Trust
    July 17, 2025
    How Health Choices and Legal Actions Intersect After an Injury
    July 17, 2025
    How communities and healthcare providers can address slip and fall injuries with legal awareness
    July 17, 2025
    Let Your Lawyer Handle the Work Before You Pay Medical Costs
    July 6, 2025
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Defending Tiered Health Plans
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Business > Hospital Administration > Defending Tiered Health Plans
BusinessHospital AdministrationNewsPolicy & LawPublic Health

Defending Tiered Health Plans

DavidEWilliams
DavidEWilliams
Share
7 Min Read
SHARE

Tiered health plans cutting costs, restricting options in today’s Boston Globe raises reasonable questions about new benefit designs from Massachusetts insurers that require members to pay more when they seek services at hospitals that are not on the preferred list.

Tiered health plans cutting costs, restricting options in today’s Boston Globe raises reasonable questions about new benefit designs from Massachusetts insurers that require members to pay more when they seek services at hospitals that are not on the preferred list. The article profiles Glenn McCarthy, a 48 year old man from Weymouth who faces $4500 in out-of-pocket costs after obtaining services at 2 hospitals that are in the higher cost tier. I empathize with the man and his wife, but overall I’m very much in favor of the availability of tiered plans like his.

To summarize the story:

  • McCarthy was told he needed surgery for “an aggressive form of prostate cancer”
  • He could have surgery at Faulkner Hospital in “more than a month” where his co-pay would be just $150
  • He could have surgery at the Brigham and Women’s in about 2 weeks –with the same surgeon– but he’d have to make a $1000 co-payment because the Brigham is in a higher cost tier for the Blue Cross Blue Shield plan he has
  • He opted to go to the Brigham because “his doctor advised against a delay.”
  • He had complications after surgery and went to South Shore Hospital in Weymouth, also in the higher cost tier, and racked up another $3500 in out-of-pocket expenses

I don’t know the specifics of the case and am not a clinician, but I’m going to go ahead and make some observations about this situation anyway.

More Read

How Has Healthcare Reform Impacted Hospitals?
5 Major Challenges in Healthcare Recruitment Today
Beyond the Buzz: Ten Tips for Healthcare Tweeters
How Chatbots And AI In The Healthcare Sector Are Changing The Industry
Treating the Healthy
  • It’s noteworthy but not surprising that the same surgeon was going to perform the surgery whether at the Faulkner of the Brigham. Have a look at the Faulkner website and you’ll see it’s actually branded as a Brigham and Women’s Hospital. It’s not just some off-price, low tech competitor as the article implies. The home page features a big come-on for the Brigham and Women’s Center for Robotic Surgery at Faulkner Hospital
  • I’m skeptical about the scheduling delay. Sure it would be a drag to have to wait more than a month for urgent surgery, but even the two week timeframe for the Brigham isn’t very impressive. Maybe the McCarthy’s don’t know how to navigate the system, but I’m willing to bet that a well-informed consumer and the surgeon could have had the timing pushed up if it was medically necessary
  • It’s too bad McCarthy got complications and then went to his local hospital, which is also in the higher tier. (By the way, can you imagine how the story would have read if McCarthy had gone to the Faulkner and ended up with complications. Would the article have blamed that on the lower end hospital?) But his situation is the exception, because very few hospitals in Massachusetts are actually in the higher tier. Two lower tier hospitals –Quincy Medical Center (part of Steward) and Milton Hospital (part of Beth Israel Deaconess)– are within 10 miles of Weymouth

Certainly $4500 is an unwelcome expense, one that the McCarthy’s are struggling to pay off. And yet it’s small change in the context of overall health care costs and even relative to the costs of the McCarthy’s health insurance.

A typical Massachusetts family health insurance premium is in the range of $1500 per month or $18,000 per year. (I don’t know what the McCarthy’s pay.) At that rate, the $4500 represents only 3 months of premium. Meanwhile, tiered plans are priced at least 12 percent below non-tiered plans. That means about $2200 per year on an $18,000 policy. So even if McCarthy wanted to go to higher tier hospitals he’d still break even financially as long as he only had this type of unfortunate episode once every two years.

In the meantime we need to consider tiered networks more broadly than just this case. Consider:

  • The introduction of tiered networks has enabled the Massachusetts Health Connector to enroll everyone who qualifies for fully subsidized insurance, despite the state’s difficult fiscal situation
  • Tiering is meant to incorporate quality as well as costs. The two should generally trend in tandem, e.g., if costs of complications are included
  • The ratings are not static and hospitals can shift between tiers year-to-year. I would expect South Shore Hospital to do everything it can to get onto the lower tier list. Why shouldn’t they be as cost-effective as Quincy and Milton?
  • I am sympathetic to the plight of high cost, prestigious hospitals such as the Brigham. But they, too, can make improvements or reconfigure their networks. For example, I would argue that the Faulkner affiliation is a good example of how this can be done
  • I note that Dana Farber and Children’s are upset about being listed on the higher tier. I know that I would want those hospitals in my network. Yet this may also provide an opportunity for Blue Cross or its competitors to add benefit designs that have multiple tiers rather than just two, or for these institutions to demonstrate that their higher quality justifies their higher costs
  • Hospital systems such as Steward have an opportunity to carve out a major market opportunity as high efficiency, high quality hospital systems –and inject some welcome “value” competition into the provider market


TAGGED:Massachusettstiered health plans
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5kFollowersLike
4.5kFollowersFollow
2.8kFollowersPin
136kSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

botox certification
Help Improve People’s Skin Health Via Botox Certification
Skin Specialties
July 22, 2025
Telemedicine Apps
Why Custom Telemedicine Apps Outperform Off‑the‑Shelf Solutions
Health
July 20, 2025
Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
How IT and Marketing Teams Can Collaborate to Protect Patient Trust
Global Healthcare Policy & Law
July 17, 2025
paramedics in surgical gloves and masks
How Health Choices and Legal Actions Intersect After an Injury
Health care
July 16, 2025

You Might also Like

Health care

Here’s What To Know And Expect About The Future Of Healthcare

January 22, 2020
medical erros avoid
Medical EthicsPolicy & Law

How to Report Medication Errors and Why It’s Important

November 17, 2024
what are the warning signs of a brain injury
NewsPolicy & Law

Which Part of The Brain Is Affected After An Accident?

July 5, 2022

5 reasons why patient engagement is critical for pharma

July 5, 2016
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2025 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?