By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    photo of hands with blue veins
    8 Proven Tips on Finding Difficult Veins
    November 12, 2021
    tips for getting over the pandemic blues
    4 Proven Ways to Get Over the Pandemic Blues
    February 22, 2022
    medical industry innovations
    How is CNC Machining Transforming the Medical Industry?
    June 2, 2022
    Latest News
    Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
    May 16, 2025
    Learn how to Renew your Medical Card in West Virginia
    May 16, 2025
    Choosing the Right Supplement Manufacturer for Your Brand
    May 1, 2025
    Engineering Temporary Hospitals for Extreme Weather
    April 24, 2025
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    Doctors on Google: Manhattan Research Survey 2012
    July 23, 2012
    HealthCare’s Need for Transparency Goes Far Beyond Pricing
    December 10, 2012
    Medicare Payments to Providers Are Carved, Sliced and Chopped by Sequestration
    March 25, 2013
    Latest News
    Building Smarter Care Teams: Aligning Roles, Structure, and Clinical Expertise
    May 18, 2025
    The Critical Role of Healthcare in Personal Injury Recovery: A Comprehensive Guide for Victims
    May 14, 2025
    The Backbone of Successful Trials: Clinical Data Management
    April 28, 2025
    Advancing Your Healthcare Career through Education and Specialization
    April 16, 2025
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: All Payor Claims Databases: ERISA Pre-emption and the Tragedy of the Commons
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Health Reform > All Payor Claims Databases: ERISA Pre-emption and the Tragedy of the Commons
BusinessHealth ReformNewsPolicy & Law

All Payor Claims Databases: ERISA Pre-emption and the Tragedy of the Commons

David Harlow
Last updated: March 8, 2016 5:23 pm
David Harlow
Share
7 Min Read
Processed with VSCOcam with acg preset
SHARE
Processed with VSCOcam with acg preset

The Supreme Court handed down its decision in Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual on March 1, holding that ERISA pre-empts Vermont’s all-payor claims database statute to the extent that it relates to self-insured plans.

Processed with VSCOcam with acg preset

The Supreme Court handed down its decision in Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual on March 1, holding that ERISA pre-empts Vermont’s all-payor claims database statute to the extent that it relates to self-insured plans. In other words, self-insured health plans (provided by large employers to 93 million covered individuals nationwide as an alternative to insurance … though they are generally administered by health insurance companies) are not required to participate in state-level health data collection efforts, even though “APCD data about health care use and cost can contribute to effective policy decisions.” (RWJF Primer on APCD Basics.) About twenty states have APCDs in place and about another dozen or so have them in the works — but they can no longer collect information on close to 1/3 of Americans.

As any health policy wonk will tell you, APCDs are valuable instruments of change, because they allow a view behind the curtain that is generally available only with respect to Medicare beneficiaries. While that data is useful it is obviously not as representative of the broader population as data regarding tens of millions of working adults and their dependents. Vermont’s law (like other APCD laws)

is designed to help identify health care needs and inform health care policy, evaluate the effectiveness of intervention programs on improving patient outcomes, compare costs between various treatment settings and approaches, determine the capacity and distribution of existing resources, and provide information to purchasers of healthcare.

(Interestingly, one must read the dissenting opinion to find this excerpt from the Vermont statute; the majority opinion is a mechanistic exercise in ERISA pre-emption without delving too deeply into that which is being pre-empted. It seems to overstep one of the precepts of ERISA pre-emption jurisprudence: “avoiding the clause’s susceptibility to limitless application.”)

More Read

Image
Healthcare Search Engine Optimization
The Intersection of Speed and Safety: Understanding the Health Implications of Deportive Car Accidents
Is Southern Europe’s Debt Crisis an Omen for US Health Care?
Top 7 Reasons a Busy Doctor Needs a Powerful Website
Grading Media Coverage: Gary Schwitzer Holds Health Journalists’ Feet to the Fire

The essence of Liberty Mutual’s argument in support of pre-emption is that it is just too darn hard to deal with multiple state regulatory schemes and file information that is similar, but not exactly the same, above and beyond the filings that self-insured plans must submit to the U.S. Department of Labor. Interesting claim … particularly in light of the fact that these filings are being made by plan administrators on behalf of self-insured plans, mostly on an automated basis, in about twenty states, and Liberty Mutual had to instruct BCBS of MA (its TPA) to stop making filings on its behalf while it continued to so do on behalf of other clients.

I won’t repeat the full reasoning of the majority opinion here — it’s technical ERISA pre-emption-speak at its finest — but please feel free to read pages 5-13 of the majority opinion, linked to above. ERISA pre-empts any state law that “relates to” employee benefit plans; even after going through various analyses intended to avoid the “limitless application” problem the majority found as it did.

Justice Breyer’s concurring opinion noted that Treasury, Labor and HHS said they were considering rulemaking under the ACA that would require health plans to make more detailed filings about various aspects of plan administration. He suggests that Labor could promulgate reporting requirements by regulation, and call for information that states want, and delegate information collection duties to the states.

Those are a lot of steps, and a lot could go wrong — or these steps might never be taken at all.

The dissenters take what sounds to me to be a more rational view of the case: ERISA reporting by plans to the Department of Labor “relates to” the plans themselves, their solvency, their ability to deliver benefits to their members when needed. Reporting to APCDs relates to cost and quality of health care services, which is something else entirely. (Frankly, since Liberty Mutual’s issue is not that its ERISA sensibilities were offended, but that it does not want to engage in additional reporting, it is entirely possible that if the regulations described in Breyer’s opinion were promulgated, another challenge could be brought regarding the authority of the agencies to develop such rules — since, as observed in the dissent and noted above, TPAs seem to have figured out how to do the requisite reporting into APCDs pretty easily.)

It’s the tragedy of the commons. The Court, the states, the federal agencies will all wait for someone to step up and lead … and it is quite possible that nobody will. It is also likely that self-insured plans will not participate voluntarily in APCD data collection going forward. Each will save some money by not going through the exercise of reporting, but all plans (ERISA plans and others) and all states (acting as Medicaid funders, and as employers providing insurance to their employees and dependents, and as fifty laboratories trying to get health reform right), and all of us, ending up unable to leverage the tremendous amount of data that should be available to us all to improve health care delivery and payment systems in this country.

The APCDs are being used for good — a key tool in state efforts to control cost and quality of health care services. If they become a shell of their former selves, as they must following this decision, who loses? We all do.

David Harlow
The Harlow Group LLC
Health Care Law and Consulting

You should follow me on Twitter: @healthblawg
TAGGED:ERISAhealth insurancesupreme court
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share
By David Harlow
Follow:
DAVID HARLOW is Principal of The Harlow Group LLC, a health care law and consulting firm based in the Hub of the Universe, Boston, MA. His thirty years’ experience in the public and private sectors affords him a unique perspective on legal, policy and business issues facing the health care community. David is adept at assisting clients in developing new paradigms for their business organizations, relationships and processes so as to maximize the realization of organizational goals in a highly regulated environment, in realms ranging from health data privacy and security to digital health strategy to physician-hospital relationships to the avoidance of fraud and abuse. He's been called "an expert on HIPAA and other health-related law issues [who] knows more than virtually anyone on those topics.” (Forbes.com.) His award-winning blog, HealthBlawg, is highly regarded in both the legal and health policy blogging worlds. David is a charter member of the external Advisory Board of the Mayo Clinic Social Media Network and has served as the Public Policy Chair of the Society for Participatory Medicine, on the Health Law Section Council of the Massachusetts Bar Association and on the Advisory Board of FierceHealthIT. He speaks regularly before health care and legal industry groups on business, policy and legal matters. You should follow him on Twitter.

Stay Connected

1.5kFollowersLike
4.5kFollowersFollow
2.8kFollowersPin
136kSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

Clinical Expertise
Building Smarter Care Teams: Aligning Roles, Structure, and Clinical Expertise
Health care
May 18, 2025
Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
Grounded Healing: A Natural Ally for Sustainable Healthcare Systems
Health
May 15, 2025
Learn how to Renew your Medical Card in West Virginia
Learn how to Renew your Medical Card in West Virginia
Health
May 15, 2025
Dr. Klaus Rentrop Shares Acute Myocardial Infarction heart treatment
Dr. Klaus Rentrop Shares Acute Myocardial Infarction
Cardiology
May 13, 2025

You Might also Like

Global Healthcare

Really Oxfam? Really?

March 14, 2011
aetna recovery programs
Addiction Recovery

The Benefits of Aetna’s Holistic Approaches to Addiction Treatment

October 11, 2023
Health carePublic HealthWellness

Look Out For These Key Signs Of Healthcare Fraud Targeting Seniors

January 8, 2019

The Top Ten Myths about Heart Disease

August 30, 2011
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2025 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?