By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    How Not to Become a Victim of Medical Scams
    How Not to Become a Victim of Medical Scams
    December 22, 2021
    11 Ways You Can Care for Your Elder Family Members Health
    11 Ways You Can Care for Your Elder Family Members Health
    April 6, 2022
    How Can Brain Injury Lead To Dangerous Long-Term Effects?
    How Can Brain Injury Lead To Dangerous Long-Term Effects?
    August 30, 2022
    Latest News
    5 Benefits Of HIPAA-Compliant Answering Services
    March 28, 2023
    3 Ways To Deal With Health Issues In Cities With High Pollution
    March 22, 2023
    What Tools Should Your Caregiver Have?
    March 22, 2023
    How to Combat Home Sickness After Moving Abroad
    March 19, 2023
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    Head And Neck Cancer: Causes, Risk Factors, Treatment, And More
    March 10, 2020
    Addressing Mental Health Problems in America’s Schools
    July 10, 2018
    health benefits of cycling
    Health Benefits Of Cycling: 3 Reasons To Go For A Bike Ride
    September 24, 2020
    Latest News
    What Are Bioidentical Hormones Made With?
    March 23, 2023
    Cover Medical Costs of Child Dog Bites with Legal Specialists
    March 23, 2023
    3 Ways to Improve the U.S. Healthcare System By 2030
    March 14, 2023
    6 Steps To Ensure Speed And Efficiency Of Clinical Studies
    March 14, 2023
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Myth Busters #6: Certificate of Need
Share
Sign In
Notification Show More
Latest News
relation between Trauma and Chronic Pain
Understanding the Relationship Between Trauma and Chronic Pain
News Wellness
hipaa-compliant answering services
5 Benefits Of HIPAA-Compliant Answering Services
Policy & Law
Diabetes Diet myths
8 Diabetes Diet Myths That Have You Confused
Diabetes
choose the right rehab center
The Road to Recovery: Finding the Best Rehab Center
Addiction Recovery
blockchain in healthcare for the NHS
How Blockchain Can Help the National Health Service
Technology
Aa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Aa
Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Business > Hospital Administration > Myth Busters #6: Certificate of Need
Hospital Administration

Myth Busters #6: Certificate of Need

JohnCGoodman
Last updated: 2011/08/19 at 3:30 PM
JohnCGoodman
Share
8 Min Read
SHARE

So, national health planning was repealed, and hospital rate setting was repealed in all but Maryland — all after wasting many billions of dollars and who knows how much pain and suffering to patients.

So, national health planning was repealed, and hospital rate setting was repealed in all but Maryland — all after wasting many billions of dollars and who knows how much pain and suffering to patients.

Yet one similar command and control program keeps ticking along — Certificate of Need (CON). Certificate of Need programs require hospitals and many other facilities to get permission from a state agency before making capital investments in new buildings, equipment, or services. The thinking behind it is, once again, based on Roemer’s Law — the more providers there are, the more spending there will be, because patients are gullible puppets doing whatever the Greedy Doctors tell them to do.

 

More Read

saving money in healthcare

Best Money-Saving Tips for Health Managers

HR Must Navigate Polarizing Views in Healthcare Workplaces
Should Hospitals Use SASE or Traditional Network Security?
Maximizing Outcomes Through Effective Patient Engagement Strategies
Robotic Technologies Can Improve Hospital Working Conditions

The National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) publishes state-by-state information on state CON laws, including the scope of affected entities and contact information for each program. It also includes a brief history of the program.

As the NCSL points out, one of the earliest and most vigorous advocates of CON was the American Hospital Association (AHA). If this surprises you, you might want to consider getting out of the office more often.

You may think we live in a capitalist economy, or in some cases socialist. But in health care, we are still in a mercantilist system, featuring a guild of select providers, who are protected from competition by the government.

The support of the AHA once again belies Roemer’s Law. If it were true that “a built bed is a filled bed,” the AHA would oppose CON because demand is unlimited and there are plenty of patients to fill every bed that could ever be built, and plenty of money to pay for it.  In fact, the AHA knows perfectly well that demand is limited, and it wants its members to be the only ones allowed to fill that limited demand.

These incumbent providers will fight tooth and nail to prevent competitors from coming in to their market area. As a result, prospective competitors have to spend very large amounts of money and time on attorneys, economists, accountants, architects, and public relations firms just on the approval process.

Even then, they may not be able to overcome the corruption of the approval boards, which opens the door for more corruption. After all, when a mere handful of people on a panel determine whether your $300 million hospital will be built or not, it is hard not to slip them some favors to get the okay. Illinois was the poster child of such graft under the reign of Gov. Rob Blagojevich. (See Mark Todd Engler’s blogs on CON in that state.)

Political corruption aside, CON is a fundamentally flawed idea. It assumes that each community has only so many consumers who can sensibly fill only so many beds, so any “overbuilding” is wasteful. (One might think that it would be wasteful only of the investors’ dollars — if they are overbuilding, they will lose their money. But that is not how social planners think.)

In fact, a new facility is not confined to serving the number of patients located in that community. A world-class facility will attract patients from all over the country, and from all over the globe.

For example, Washington state blocked the construction of new facilities that might have prospered by serving citizens from British Columbia and the Pacific Rim, because the CON Board tallied up the number of Seattle residents, divided by the number of existing beds, and declared there were already enough beds to serve Seattle. Thus, the state killed off what was a promising economic development program for Seattle, one that might have created thousands of new jobs and millions in new tax revenue. For more about Washington state’s CON program, see “The Failure of Government Central Planning: Washington’s Medical Certificate of Need Program,” by John Barnes.

CON also stifles innovation and improved quality. Existing providers who are accustomed to doing things in a certain way are protected from being challenged by new, more efficient, competitors. In 2004, the Federal Trade Commission and the Department of Justice released a joint study, “Improving Health Care: A Dose of Competition,” urging states to:

Reconsider whether Certificate of Need Programs best serve their citizens’ health care needs. On balance, the DOJ and the FTC believe that such programs are not successful in containing health care costs, and they pose serious anticompetitive risks that usually outweigh their purported economic benefits.

At a minimum these “purported benefits” should include some reduction in the costs of health care spending. But Christopher Conover and Frank Sloan of Duke University were unable to detect such an effect in a study they conducted, “Does Removing Certificate-of-Need Regulations Lead to a Surge in Health Care Spending?” The authors write:

Mature CON programs are associated with a modest (5 percent) long-term reductionin acute care spending per capita, but not with a significant reduction in total per capita spending. There is no evidenceof a surge in acquisition of facilities or in costs followingremoval of CON regulations. Mature CON programs also resultin a slight (2 percent) reduction in bed supply but higher costsper day and per admission, along with higher hospital profits.CON regulations generally have no detectable effect on diffusionof various hospital-based technologies.

That study was conducted in 1998. Today it is far more likely that CON will be shown to have raised costs after the dramatic consolidation of the hospital industry, especially in CON states. Monopoly providers can charge whatever they like, and have no fear that health plans will refuse to include them in their networks. How many people will enroll in a health plan that doesn’t cover the only hospital in their locale?

CON has been an amazing success story for the American Hospital Association and it members, but it has been disastrous for the American consumer and taxpayer.

   

TAGGED: certificate of need, hospitals

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
JohnCGoodman August 19, 2011
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Share
Previous Article Top Quotes of the Week
Next Article 19 Ways to Recognize You’re a Neonatal Therapist

Stay Connected

1.5k Followers Like
4.5k Followers Follow
2.8k Followers Pin
136k Subscribers Subscribe

Latest News

relation between Trauma and Chronic Pain
Understanding the Relationship Between Trauma and Chronic Pain
News Wellness March 28, 2023
hipaa-compliant answering services
5 Benefits Of HIPAA-Compliant Answering Services
Policy & Law March 28, 2023
Diabetes Diet myths
8 Diabetes Diet Myths That Have You Confused
Diabetes March 28, 2023
choose the right rehab center
The Road to Recovery: Finding the Best Rehab Center
Addiction Recovery March 27, 2023

You Might also Like

medical call centers benefits
Wellness

Best Practices for Healthcare Call Centers Should Follow in 2023

February 16, 2023
employee's wellness
Health

How Hospitals and Other Healthcare Providers Can Boost Employee Morale

February 13, 2023
BusinessHospital Administration

What are the Benefits of Hospitals and Clinics Using Expense Management Services?

February 13, 2023
healthcare workers with gloves
Hospital Administration

Tips to Keep Health Workers Safe in the Workplace

February 8, 2023
//

We influence million of users and is the most authentic source of information on healthcare business and technology news.

Quick Links

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Follow US

© 2008-2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?