By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    stress disorder
    5 Ways To Manage Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
    October 27, 2021
    Medical device classification and development strategies
    Medical device classification and development strategies
    January 19, 2022
    varicose veins
    Varicose Veins Prevention: 3 Lifestyle Changes to Make Right Now
    May 1, 2022
    Latest News
    3 Ways To Deal With Health Issues In Cities With High Pollution
    March 22, 2023
    What Tools Should Your Caregiver Have?
    March 22, 2023
    How to Combat Home Sickness After Moving Abroad
    March 19, 2023
    4 Ways to Recover from a Broken Hip
    March 14, 2023
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    The Outcomes That Matter To Patients
    The Outcomes That Matter to Patients
    September 15, 2013
    Match Day Looms, Can Primary Care Once Again Show Gains?
    March 15, 2012
    healthcare topics in 2014
    Health Predictions for 2014: 6 Sources of Disease and Distress We Expect in the Coming Year
    December 16, 2013
    Latest News
    3 Ways to Improve the U.S. Healthcare System By 2030
    March 14, 2023
    6 Steps To Ensure Speed And Efficiency Of Clinical Studies
    March 14, 2023
    5 Most Valuable Healthcare Programs in 2023
    March 8, 2023
    The Everest Foundation’s Mission to Support Inclusive Healthcare
    February 24, 2023
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Stop the Pilot Programs
Share
Sign In
Notification Show More
Latest News
health issues for office workers
Biggest Health Issues Office Workers Need to Content With
News
pollution impact on health
3 Ways To Deal With Health Issues In Cities With High Pollution
Health
caregiver importance
What Tools Should Your Caregiver Have?
Medicare
boost body energy level
The Best Natural Ways to Boost Your Body Energy & Focus
Wellness
virtual reality in optometry
What Are the Implications of Virtual Reality in Optometry?
Technology
Aa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Aa
Search
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Health Reform > Stop the Pilot Programs
BusinessHealth ReformNewsPolicy & LawPublic Health

Stop the Pilot Programs

JohnCGoodman
Last updated: 2013/03/21 at 7:21 AM
JohnCGoodman
Share
8 Min Read
healthcare reform
SHARE

The federal government has been spending billions of dollars on health care pilot programs and demonstration projects. President Obama has explained their purpose: “We need to find out what works and then go do it.” In other words, the exercises are supposed to discover how to lower costs and raise quality so that everyone else can copy them.

The federal government has been spending billions of dollars on health care pilot programs and demonstration projects. President Obama has explained their purpose: “We need to find out what works and then go do it.” In other words, the exercises are supposed to discover how to lower costs and raise quality so that everyone else can copy them.

healthcare reformThere are five problems. First, three Congressional Budget Office reports (see here, here and here) have found that these programs are not working. Second, even where there is evidence of success, the gains are usually too small to warrant much hope for meaningful change. Third, no matter how successful a project, it is not of much value if it cannot be replicated — which appears to be generally the case. Fourth, even in the rare instance where a pilot program is remarkably successful and there is every reason to think the results are replicable, Washington will ignore the project if it does not fit into the bureaucratic vision of how health care should be delivered. (I produce a stunning example below.)

Fifth, and this is the real killer, we don’t need pilot programs and demonstration projects in the first place. Why? Because we have hundreds of natural experiments where costs have been lowered and quality raised without any cost to the taxpayer at all. This is because of:

More Read

valueable healthcare programs

5 Most Valuable Healthcare Programs in 2023

The Health and Legal Risks of Living in Your Vehicle
Nutrition Advice: Cut Back on Added Sugar (+ Save Money)
The Everest Foundation’s Mission to Support Inclusive Healthcare
People with Disabilities Can Access SIL Funding with the NDIS

Goodman’s law of medical innovation: For whatever we are trying to do in medicine, there is someone, somewhere, who has found a way to do it 50% better.

For almost any kind of surgery — mastectomies, knee or hip replacements, spinal fusion, etc. — there is someone in the United States who has discovered how to cut the patient recovery time in half. Partly for that reason, there is someone who has discovered how to cut the cost in half. For infection rates, readmissions and other indicators of quality care, there is some institution, somewhere, that is chalking up rates that are half that of what the country as a whole is experiencing.

If you think we can copy excellence, don’t run a demonstration project. Just go copy what’s already working and working well.

We got to stop and
Think it over.

 

Of course, in a normal market, if someone discovered how to lower costs by half for a given level of quality or to increase quality by 50% for a given level of cost, that person would have a huge advantage over his competitors. The rivals would have to quickly discover how to emulate the innovator, lest they be priced out of the market. Only in health care, where normal market processes have been systematically suppressed for decades, can widely different levels of efficiency coexist, side by side, for year after year.

How do I know that Goodman’s law is true? Because I meet people every day who appear to affirm it. Many of them have been profiled at this blog. We have posted before about American Physician Housecalls, which appears to cut the cost of care in half for chronically ill Medicare patients. To my knowledge, Health and Human Services has made no effort whatsoever to even investigate this successful venture. (They’re not ACO? Forget it!) And then there is Jeffery Brenner, the “hotspots” doctor who is saving millions of dollars for Medicare and Medicaid, and getting nothing in return. The problem: Brenner is changing patient behavior mainly through “social work” and Medicare doesn’t pay for social work. (Besides, he’s not an ACO either!)

Here’s another fascinating example (sent to me by Dr. Brenner). Health Quality Partners, in Doylestown, PA, participated in a 10-year Medicare chronic care demonstration project, with a 1,700 patient randomized control trial run by Mathematica. They used a nurse outreach model to visit the homes of frail, elderly Medicare patients. As explained by Dr. Brenner:

The project showed a 25% sustained reduction in death rates, reduced cost, and reduced hospitalization (33%). It’s really groundbreaking [with] stunning results. There are no pills or treatments that come close to these kinds of results. For the frailest patients the death rate dropped 50% and the results were sustained. They essentially discovered the fountain of youth.

So what is the federal government doing with this information? CMS is about to end the demonstration project with no plans to replicate the results.

So, back to the title of this post. There are really three questions to be asked:

  1. Are there techniques that will substantially reduce cost and/or improve quality?
  2. Will entrepreneurs discover them and implement them, given market incentives?
  3. Can a centralized planner manipulate doctor behavior in this regard, with small penalties and rewards?

The answer to the first question is clearly “yes.” The answer to the second is also “yes,” but let’s be clear about what that means. If an entrepreneur saves a million dollars for the system, he is going to want to bank, say, $500K for himself. No one is going to take big risks for a normal rate of return. Right now, no one is out there trying to copy what Dr. Brenner is doing in Camden, New Jersey, or what American Physician Housecalls is doing in Dallas, Texas, because they can’t capture a significant part of the huge value such activities create for the system.

To solve our problems with entrepreneurship, we have to free the market and let entrepreneurship bloom.

That brings us to the third question, which I think is the real reason why so much money is being spent on pilot programs when we could learn so much more without spending any money at all.

It turns out that the answer to that question is apparently “no.” Big bureaucracies cannot manipulate doctor behavior with small penalties and rewards.

Darn. The world would be so much simpler if only socialism worked.

TAGGED: ACA, pilot programs

Sign Up For Daily Newsletter

Be keep up! Get the latest breaking news delivered straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
JohnCGoodman March 21, 2013
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Copy Link Print
Share
Previous Article Alzheimer's disease facts and figures New Alzheimer’s Report: Facts and Stats Paint Grim Picture
Next Article Image Healthy Eating on the Run: Tips to Celebrate National Nutrition Month

Stay Connected

1.5k Followers Like
4.5k Followers Follow
2.8k Followers Pin
136k Subscribers Subscribe

Latest News

health issues for office workers
Biggest Health Issues Office Workers Need to Content With
News March 22, 2023
pollution impact on health
3 Ways To Deal With Health Issues In Cities With High Pollution
Health March 22, 2023
caregiver importance
What Tools Should Your Caregiver Have?
Medicare March 22, 2023
boost body energy level
The Best Natural Ways to Boost Your Body Energy & Focus
Wellness March 22, 2023

You Might also Like

health issues for office workers
News

Biggest Health Issues Office Workers Need to Content With

March 22, 2023
hair transplants for cancer patients
News

Why Reputable Hair Transplant Clinics Can Help Cancer Patients

March 21, 2023
combat home sickness
HealthNews

How to Combat Home Sickness After Moving Abroad

March 19, 2023
US healthcare system
Global Healthcare

3 Ways to Improve the U.S. Healthcare System By 2030

March 14, 2023
//

We influence million of users and is the most authentic source of information on healthcare business and technology news.

Quick Links

  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Subscribe

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Follow US

© 2008-2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?