By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
  • Health
    • Mental Health
    Health
    Healthcare organizations are operating on slimmer profit margins than ever. One report in August showed that they are even lower than the beginning of the…
    Show More
    Top News
    improving patient experience
    6 Ways to Improve Patient Satisfaction Within Hospitals
    December 1, 2021
    degree for healthcare job
    What Are The Health Benefits Of Having A Degree?
    March 9, 2022
    custom software development is changing healthcare
    Digital Customer Journey Mapping and its Importance for Healthcare
    July 21, 2022
    Latest News
    Beyond Nutrition: Everyday Foods That Support Whole-Body Health
    June 15, 2025
    The Wide-Ranging Benefits of Magnesium Supplements
    June 11, 2025
    The Best Home Remedies for Migraines
    June 5, 2025
    The Hidden Impact Of Stress On Your Body’s Alignment And Balance
    May 22, 2025
  • Policy and Law
    • Global Healthcare
    • Medical Ethics
    Policy and Law
    Get the latest updates about Insurance policies and Laws in the Healthcare industry for different geographical locations.
    Show More
    Top News
    narrow-road-ahead-sign
    Narrow Networks in California?
    March 24, 2016
    Insurer Has E-Security Problem
    August 26, 2017
    What Kind of Inequality Matters to You?
    October 19, 2011
    Latest News
    Let Your Lawyer Handle the Work Before You Pay Medical Costs
    July 6, 2025
    Top HIPAA-Compliant Messaging Apps for Healthcare Teams
    June 25, 2025
    When Healthcare Ends, the Legal Process Begins: What Families Should Know About Probate and Medical Estates
    June 20, 2025
    Preventing Contamination In Healthcare Facilities Starts With Hygiene
    June 15, 2025
  • Medical Innovations
  • News
  • Wellness
  • Tech
Search
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: You be the Judge
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Health Works CollectiveHealth Works Collective
Font ResizerAa
Search
Follow US
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
© 2023 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
Health Works Collective > Policy & Law > Medical Ethics > You be the Judge
Medical EthicsPolicy & Law

You be the Judge

Dov Michaeli
Dov Michaeli
Share
6 Min Read
SHARE

 

 

The full weight of Justice, as we see it.

 

 

The full weight of Justice, as we see it.

Imagine for a minute that you are a judge. Most of us served on juries, and pronounced verdicts of guilt and innocence. But we don’t get to decide which evidence is presented and which is suppressed. And, the task of sentencing is in the hands of the judge. But what if you are the judge?

Let me present a hypothetical case to you that is based on an actual case (Mobley v. State).
Jonathan Donahue attempted to rob a restaurant. When the manager did not give Donahue the money, Donahue struck him repeatedly in the head with a gun, resulting in moderate, permanent brain damage. A jury found Donahue guilty of aggravated battery.

At the trial evidence was presented by psychiatrist that Donahue was a diagnosed psychopath. How would that change your sentence?

Suppose now that in addition to the psychiatric testimony a neurobiologist presented an explanation of the biological mechanism contributing to the development of psychopathy Donahue had a low MAO-A activity, a brain enzyme the deficiency of which has been associated with violent behavior. Would this additional information change the way you sentenced Donahue?

If you as a judge tend to punish the criminal because we expect people to be held accountable for their actions, wouldn’t the enzyme deficiency be a mitigating factor? After all, Donahue’s capacity to control his behavior is markedly diminished, how can you hold him to same standard of responsibility as a “run of the mill” criminal?But what if you, the judge, also feel that reducing the sentence to account for the biochemical deficiency would end up exposing the community to increased danger of violence? This defect condemns the person to a life-long uncontrollable aggressive behavior.Quite a moral dilemma, Isn’t it? In fact, judges are confronted with it every day of the week. How do they resolve it?

A fascinating study published in Science ( August 17, 2012) presented 181 state trial court judges with the Donahue case. Half of them heard the psychiatrist testimony only, the other half heard the neurobiologist’s testimony as well. How did the ‘mechanism’ testimony affect the judge’s sentencing? Did the judge see the biological deficiency as beyond the control of the individual thus mitigating the severity of the offense? Or did he see the very biological inevitability of the violent behavior as a reason to keep the offender in jail as long as possible?When asked to imagine how they would rule in a sentencing hearing, the judges who read this biological explanation cited more mitigating factors (such as mental illness) and handed out modestly reduced prison sentences—13 years, on average, compared with 14 years for judges who did not see this testimony.

How would I sentence Donahue? This is a tough decision to make. My problem is not the introduction of science into the courtroom; it has brought us from the dark ages to the 21st century in a matter of a few years. DNA evidence has attained the aura of infallibility that only God had once had. Eyewitness testimony is not as trustworthy as it used to be. The lineup procedure is now subjected in many places to the scientific method to remove possible bias.

But neurobiological evidence? That’s an animal of a different stripe. Neurobiological studies are by their very nature averages of a population. On average, MAO-A deficiency predicts violent behavior. But that does not automatically extend to individual cases. There are many individuals with MAO-A deficiency who control their aggressions quite successfully.

The Salmon story

Remember the Monty Python hillarious skit of the Dead Parrot? Here is a life-imitating-art story from the “you can’t make it up” department.

 

Craig Bennet, a doctoral neurobiology student at Dartmouth put a dead Atlantic Salmon in the fMRI machine, and they showed it “a series of photographs depicting human individuals in social situations.” To maintain the rigor of the protocol (and perhaps because it was hilarious), the salmon, just like a human test subject, “was asked to determine what emotion the individual in the photo must have been experiencing.” as Wired Science (September 18, 2009) reported “when they got around to analyzing the voxel (think: 3-D or “volumetric” pixel) data, the voxels representing the area where the salmon’s tiny brain sat showed evidence of activity. In the fMRI scan, it looked like the dead salmon was actually thinking about the pictures it had been shown”.

Does that invalidate all fMRI studies? Of course not. As Bennet explains “In fMRI, you have 160,000 darts, and so just by random chance, by the noise that’s inherent in the fMRI data, you’re going to have some of those darts hit a bull’s-eye by accident.” In other words, interpretation of fMRI data requires a rigorous application of sophisticated statistics. The field is not standardized and is rife with bad studies.

The take home lesson is that brain science is still in its infancy, not ready for prime time appearance in the courtroom.

The post You be the Judge appeared first on The Doctor Weighs In.

TAGGED:healthcare law
Share This Article
Facebook Copy Link Print
Share

Stay Connected

1.5kFollowersLike
4.5kFollowersFollow
2.8kFollowersPin
136kSubscribersSubscribe

Latest News

9 Lifestyle Tweaks That Can Add Years to Your Life
9 Healthcare Lifestyle Tweaks That can Add Years to Your Life
lifestyle
July 11, 2025
car accident lawsuit
Let Your Lawyer Handle the Work Before You Pay Medical Costs
Policy & Law
July 6, 2025
women dental care
What Is a Smile Makeover and How Much Does It Cost?
Dental health
June 30, 2025
HIPAA-Compliant Messaging Apps
Top HIPAA-Compliant Messaging Apps for Healthcare Teams
Global Healthcare Policy & Law Technology
June 25, 2025

You Might also Like

doctor guilds
FinanceHealth ReformHospital AdministrationPolicy & LawPublic Health

Do All of Us Really Have to Change?

June 13, 2013
traditional hospitals
Global HealthcareTechnology

Global Study Finds Majority Believe Traditional Hospitals Will Be Obsolete in the Near Future

February 20, 2014

Midwifery in the U.S.: History, Politics, and Pathways to Practice

March 7, 2016

Head of the DOJ’s Antitrust Division Raises Concerns About Two Proposed Mega-Mergers Between Leading Health Insurers

November 20, 2015
Subscribe
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Follow US
© 2008-2025 HealthWorks Collective. All Rights Reserved.
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?